Read time: 1 min

HPC Urges the FCA to Treat Public Blockchains as Neutral Infrastructure

HPC Urges the FCA to Treat Public Blockchains as Neutral Infrastructure

HPC Urges the FCA to Treat Public Blockchains as Neutral Infrastructure

Regulated firms in the United Kingdom are increasingly using public blockchains as infrastructure for the products they offer to their clients. In this broader trend, which we describe as onchain finance, an identifiable and accountable firm remains responsible for its product, and that product inherits the transparency, continuous availability, and settlement efficiency of the public blockchain on which it runs. How UK firms can leverage blockchain technology will depend on how the Financial Conduct Authority (“FCA”) applies the regulatory perimeter where the functions that a single firm once performed are distributed across many participants. It will also depend on the FCA’s expectations of firms whose products run on infrastructure they do not control.

On a public blockchain, the activities that a single firm typically performs in traditional markets, such as operating the venue, matching orders, and settling trades, are spread across a wider range of participants. A public blockchain provides shared infrastructure that regulated firms can use to offer products to their customers, but the blockchain itself is maintained by validators (the network participants who verify transactions) and developers who contribute to a network’s software. In our view, infrastructure providers like validators and developers do not engage in regulated activity because they do not have unilateral control over products offered onchain.

A person who maintains unilateral control over a regulated element of an onchain product, such as the ability to alter or suspend transactions, is an appropriate subject for tailored compliance obligations. If no one has control over such a product, then any person offering the product to end users must be able to meet the relevant obligations through other means. If an onchain product cannot be offered in a way that satisfies applicable regulations, the solution is to exclude the product from the UK market, rather than placing compliance obligations on infrastructure providers who have no way to meet them.

The UK is now bringing cryptoasset activities within its regulatory perimeter. From October 25, 2027, firms carrying on any of the new regulated cryptoasset activities will require authorization from the FCA.

In October, the FCA published two consultations that address the application of UK financial regulation to activity on public blockchains. Consultation Paper CP26/36 proposes additions to the FCA’s perimeter guidance (the part of its regulations that explains when an activity requires authorization), including on decentralization and on exclusions for proprietary trading and for technical service providers. Guidance Consultation GC26/7 sets out how regulated firms that provide financial services using onchain infrastructure should manage the resulting operational resilience and financial crime risks.

HPC supports the technology-neutral approach underlying the FCA’s draft guidance. We agree that whether a person falls within the regulatory perimeter depends on the activities and functions it performs, rather than on the technology through which it performs them. We encouraged the same approach in our response to the European Commission’s review of MiCA, the EU’s framework for cryptoasset markets.

Today, HPC filed responses to both of the FCA’s consultations. Our responses encourage the FCA to attach obligations to the persons who control regulated activities and to the regulated firms that serve clients, to treat public blockchains as neutral infrastructure, and to recognize that persons who validate transactions or develop software supporting that infrastructure do not, on that basis alone, carry on a regulated activity. Regulated firms already rely on the public internet on the same basis, without internet service providers and other network participants becoming subject to the regulation that applies to the firms themselves.

Whether a public blockchain counts as a “decentralized protocol” under the proposed exclusion for technical service providers should depend on whether any person can unilaterally control how its rules apply to users. The legislation does not define the term, which leaves room for a technology that continues to evolve, and the FCA’s draft guidance rightly interprets the term by reference to how the relevant arrangements operate in practice. We welcome the FCA’s recognition that a blockchain network may qualify as a decentralized protocol even though identifiable persons contribute to the development, maintenance, or governance of its software.  Public blockchains generally require ongoing maintenance and reward the validators that secure them, so if either feature were enough to disqualify a network, few public blockchains could qualify.

Public blockchains can also help regulated firms meet their operational resilience and financial crime obligations. A network maintained by a distributed set of validators continues to operate when an individual validator fails, which avoids the single points of failure that can arise when a firm relies on one service provider for a critical function. A public blockchain also records every transaction publicly and in sequence, so firms can trace funds directly within that ledger and supervisors can reconstruct an incident without depending on the affected firm’s own records.

Our response asks the FCA to make seven clarifications in the final guidance:

  1. State expressly that where a regulated firm uses a public blockchain to deliver a regulated product, the obligations rest with that firm, and its use of the network does not of itself bring the network, or participants who do not carry on regulated activities, within scope.

  2. Confirm that the perimeter analysis applies separately to each person, by reference to the functions it performs, and that any resulting obligations cover only the regulated activity to which those functions relate.

  3. Confirm that the “by way of business” factors are assessed by reference to the regulated activity a person carries on, since operating validator infrastructure or developing software can be a genuine business without being a regulated activity.

  4. Confirm that the retail-counterparty expectation applies only to bilateral dealing, and not where a proprietary trader’s orders match a retail investor’s through a multilateral order book.

  5. Confirm that a user who chooses an interface connected to a single service provider or protocol has selected that provider or protocol for the purposes of the technical services exclusion, and anchor the test for a decentralized protocol to unilateral control.

  6. Confirm that firms relying on public blockchain infrastructure can meet their operational resilience obligations through the requirements the draft guidance already sets out.

  7. Express any requirement to build compliance tools into networks or protocols as an outcome that the relevant regulated firms are accountable for achieving, and consider recognizing onchain verifiability as a means of meeting transparency and recordkeeping objectives.

The FCA can make each of these clarifications in its final guidance, without new legislation or any change to the statutory perimeter. 

The UK’s new regime will shape who requires authorization in onchain markets. Where regulatory obligations track the activities and functions that each person performs, regulated firms can build on public blockchains with confidence, and the networks beneath them can remain open to all participants. HPC looks forward to continued engagement with the FCA as both consultations proceed.

Read our full response here.

TAGS
Washington,D.C.
08:43 AM
Washington,D.C.
08:43 AM

est. 2026

© 2024 HYPERLIQUID POLICY CENTER

BASED IN Washington,D.C.

est. 2026

© 2024 HYPERLIQUID POLICY CENTER